The “flipped classroom” was being discussed in social lounges, in conference sessions, on the exhibit floor, on thehashtag and even at dinner. People wanted to know what it was, what it wasn’t, how it’s done and why it works. Others wanted to sing its praises and often included a vignette about how it works in their classroom and how it transformed learning for their students. Still others railed that the model is nothing transformative at all and that it still emphasizes sage-on-the-stage direct instruction rather than student-centered learning. I engaged in a few of these discussions offline and online, and while I’m still on the fence about my feelings toward the model, I can offer some insight and interpretation.